Policy Area
Chapter 5: The Democratic Argument
Why do we want as many people as possible to back Scotland’s right to decide it’s own future?
The reason is because Scotland could find itself living in a state where our right to determine our own constitutional future is lost.
What examples can you provide of Westminster politicians saying Scotland is part of a voluntary union?
Before the independence referendum in 2014, Westminster political leaders across the UK and across the political spectrum characterised the Union as an equal partnership
What proof is there of an agreed principle that a change in Scotland’s constitutional status should be a matter for the Scottish people?
For decades Westminster politicians claimed the United Kingdom is a voluntary union of nations, or a union of equals; that its existence depends on the continued consent of its parts.
What is the democratic argument for Scottish independence?
Scotland’s democracy is stronger and healthier than Westminster’s – and Scottish voters have repeatedly given their government a mandate to pursue independence. Here’s the democratic argument for why Scotland should be an independent country.
What makes Scotland a nation?
The people of Scotland have a long and proud history – and see themselves as a nation. We have our own culture, politics and institutions – and unlimited potential.
Is the UK a partnership of equal nations?
Westminster frequently sidelines, overrules and ignores the decisions of the devolved governments. It’s a myth that Scotland is in a union of equals.
What difference has devolution made in Scotland?
Devolution has strengthened the voice of Scottish voters, enhanced our democracy and made Scotland a better place. Imagine how much further we could go with the full powers of independence.
Why can’t Scotland make all decisions over issues like energy and the economy?
Westminster shouldn’t control these policies – the decisions affecting Scotland should be made by the people who live here.
What is the impact of Brexit?
Both Labour and the Tories have inflicted a damaging Brexit on Scotland that we didn’t vote for.
Have people in Scotland voted for an independence referendum?
Scotland has repeatedly voted for a second independence referendum, with its wishes ignored by Westminster.